🔗 Share this article

One of the most iconic images from modern history depicts an unclothed girl, her limbs spread wide, her expression distorted in pain, her body blistered and raw. She appears dashing in the direction of the photographer after running from a bombing within the conflict. Nearby, additional kids also run out of the bombed village of the region, with a scene of thick fumes and the presence of troops.

This Worldwide Effect from an Seminal Image

Within hours the publication in June 1972, this picture—formally named "Napalm Girl"—evolved into an analog hit. Seen and discussed globally, it is broadly hailed for galvanizing public opinion critical of the conflict in Vietnam. An influential thinker afterwards observed that this profoundly unforgettable picture of nine-year-old Kim Phúc suffering possibly was more effective to increase global outrage against the war than extensive footage of broadcast atrocities. A legendary English photojournalist who reported on the war labeled it the single best photograph of what would later be called the televised conflict. A different experienced war journalist declared that the picture stands as quite simply, a pivotal photos ever made, particularly of the Vietnam war.

The Decades-Long Attribution Followed by a Modern Claim

For half a century, the photo was attributed to a South Vietnamese photographer, a then-21-year-old local photojournalist on assignment for an international outlet during the war. However a disputed new documentary released by a global network contends that the famous image—often hailed as the peak of war journalism—was actually shot by someone else present that day during the attack.

As presented in the film, the iconic image was actually taken by a stringer, who sold his work to the organization. The claim, and the film’s subsequent investigation, stems from a man named an ex-staffer, who claims how a powerful photo chief directed the staff to change the photograph's attribution from the freelancer to Nick Út, the one AP staff photographer on site at the time.

The Quest for the Truth

The former editor, advanced in years, contacted an investigator recently, requesting support to locate the unnamed cameraman. He stated how, if he could be found, he wanted to extend an apology. The investigator reflected on the independent photographers he knew—likening them to modern freelancers, who, like independent journalists during the war, are routinely ignored. Their work is commonly questioned, and they function amid more challenging circumstances. They lack insurance, they don’t have pensions, minimal assistance, they usually are without good equipment, making them extremely at risk as they capture images within their homeland.

The investigator asked: How would it feel for the man who captured this image, should it be true that it wasn't Nick Út?” As a photographer, he speculated, it would be profoundly difficult. As an observer of the craft, specifically the highly regarded war photography of the era, it might be reputation-threatening, possibly career-damaging. The revered history of "Napalm Girl" in the diaspora meant that the filmmaker with a background emigrated during the war was reluctant to pursue the film. He said, I hesitated to challenge the established story attributed to Nick the picture. And I didn’t want to disturb the status quo of a community that always respected this success.”

This Investigation Develops

But the two the investigator and the creator concluded: it was important posing the inquiry. When reporters must keep the world in the world,” noted the journalist, it is essential that we are willing to ask difficult questions about our own field.”

The documentary documents the investigators as they pursue their own investigation, from testimonies from observers, to requests in present-day Ho Chi Minh City, to examining footage from other footage recorded at the time. Their search finally produce an identity: a freelancer, employed by NBC during the attack who sometimes sold photographs to the press as a freelancer. According to the documentary, a moved the claimant, currently in his 80s residing in the US, states that he sold the famous picture to the AP for $20 and a copy, but was haunted by not being acknowledged over many years.

The Response Followed by Further Scrutiny

The man comes across throughout the documentary, quiet and reflective, but his story proved incendiary within the community of journalism. {Days before|Shortly prior to